Most homemade recipes are harmless even when they do nothing. A small number are genuinely dangerous, and they circulate as widely as the useful ones. These are the ones worth knowing about.
What must never be mixed?
- Bleach and any acid – vinegar, lemon juice, citric acid, limescale remover or toilet cleaner. Produces chlorine gas.
- Bleach and ammonia – found in some glass cleaners and multi surface sprays. Produces chloramine vapour.
- Bleach and rubbing alcohol – produces chloroform and other harmful compounds.
- Hydrogen peroxide and vinegar in one container – produces peracetic acid, corrosive and irritating.
- Two different drain products, particularly an acid after an alkali.
The first two matter most because they happen accidentally, when one product is used after another in a small bathroom without rinsing in between.
Why is the bathroom the risky room?
Because it is small, often poorly ventilated, and it is where people most commonly use two products in sequence: a limescale spray and then a bleach based toilet cleaner, or a mould remover after a descaler.
Use one product at a time, rinse thoroughly between them, and ventilate throughout.
What about the peroxide and vinegar spray?
Widely shared as a disinfectant. Used one after the other with a rinse in between, they are safe and effective, which is how the original research applied them.
Mixed in a single bottle they produce peracetic acid, which is corrosive and irritating to eyes, skin and lungs. Keep them in separate bottles.
Which recipes are ineffective rather than dangerous?
- Vinegar and bicarbonate mixed together, which neutralise each other and leave salty water.
- Vinegar as a disinfectant, which is far weaker than the claims.
- Essential oils as the active ingredient, at domestic dilutions.
- Homemade enzyme cleaners from fruit peel and sugar, which are mildly acidic rather than enzymatic.
- Salt on wine stains, which absorbs a little liquid and does nothing to the pigment.
What about homemade laundry detergent?
The common recipe of grated soap, borax and washing soda is popular and performs poorly in modern machines. Soap reacts with hard water to form scum, which deposits on clothes and in the machine, causing greyness and a build up that eventually smells.
It also contains no enzymes, no oxygen bleach and no optical brighteners. It is one of the few cases where the commercial product is substantially better.
What about homemade dishwasher tablets?
Similar problems. Recipes using soda crystals, salt and citric acid lack the enzymes and the specific surfactants a dishwasher detergent needs, and the results are typically cloudy glasses and poorly cleaned dishes.
What should never be made at home?
Anything caustic, since handling concentrated sodium hydroxide is genuinely hazardous and it reacts violently with water. Any concentrated acid solution. And anything decanted into a container that could be mistaken for food or drink.
What about storage mistakes?
Never store a homemade cleaner in a drinks bottle, which is a recognised route to accidental poisoning, particularly with children. Never leave a mixture unlabelled. And never store anything that produces gas in a sealed bottle, since pressure builds.
What are the safe alternatives?
For disinfecting, dilute bleach used alone with a proper contact time, or surgical spirit, or heat. For limescale, vinegar or citric acid used alone. For grease, soda crystals or washing up liquid. For stains, oxygen bleach mixed fresh.
Each does its job well on its own, and none of them needs combining with anything else.
What is the general rule?
One product at a time. If a recipe combines two active ingredients, ask what each is and whether they are opposites. If one is a bleach, the answer is to use nothing else with it.
What if you have mixed something by accident?
Leave the room immediately, open windows and doors from outside the space if you can do so safely, and do not go back in until it has ventilated thoroughly. Anyone experiencing coughing, chest tightness or eye irritation should get into fresh air and seek medical advice. Do not attempt to clear up the mixture while the fumes are present.